| | Putin, on Guard for 2018 World Cup in Russia, Denounces FIFA Arrests - New York Times | EU referendum: David Cameron pushes leaders on reforms - BBC News | Splintered Nigeria needs a shared vision - Mail & Guardian Online | Syrian Islamist rebels 'seize Ariha in Idlib province' - BBC News | Car bombs outside two Baghdad hotels kill at least 10, Iraqi authorities say - ABC Online | Nearly 500 bodies exhumed from graves in Iraq, morgue official - CNN | Police reveal a dozen Melbourne girls fled our safe suburbs to join Islamic State - Herald Sun | Bartender sentenced after man drinks 56 shots and dies - Stuff.co.nz | Britain's Oxford University nominates 1st female vice-chancellor in its history - Fox News | New Nigerian President Looks to Shrink Government - Wall Street Journal | | Latest on flooding: Rising water cuts off Texas subdivisions - Chron.com | Feds indict ex-House Speaker Hastert for allegedly hiding payments to apparent ... - Fox News | 1 killed as Chula Vista gunman remains barricaded but releases hostages - Los Angeles Times | Cool things about the National Spelling Bee finalists - USA TODAY | The Latest: Video shows Holmes saying he regrets attack - Washington Post | Virginia panel issues proposals to fight campus sex assaults - SFGate | The Iowa straw poll, once a kingmaker, fades into irrelevance for 2016 - Washington Post | Report Completed on Police Shooting of Washington State Man - ABC News | Man charged with arson in massive downtown LA fire pleads not guilty - Los Angeles Times | Baltimore's crime spike raises both police and civilian fear - CBS News | | Feds indict ex-House Speaker Hastert for allegedly hiding payments to apparent ... - Fox News | THE LATEST: US Will Vote for Prince Ali in FIFA Election - New York Times | The Short List: National Spelling Bee; our new ancestor; biolab accidents - USA TODAY | First Draft | Chris Christie Ready to Desert Common Core Standards - New York Times | The Latest: Video shows Holmes saying he regrets attack - Washington Post | George Pataki Adds a Socially Liberal Voice to the Race for the GOP Nomination - New York Times | Was Pentagon's shipment of live anthrax "human error"? - CBS News | Jeb Bush in Michigan calls for 'radical' education changes - USA TODAY | First Draft | Hillary Clinton Plans Livelier Campaign Schedule for June - New York Times | Obama holds climate (and basketball) Q&A on Twitter - BBC News
Mar 302013
 

JUSTICE KAGAN: Mr. Clement, for the most part and historically, the only uniformity that the Federal Government has pursued is that it’s uniformly recognized the marriages that are recognized by the State. So, this was a real difference in the uniformity that the Federal Government was pursuing. And it suggests that maybe something — maybe Congress had something different in mind than uniformity.
So we have a whole series of cases which suggest the following: Which suggest that when Congress targets a group that is not everybody’s favorite group in the world, that we look at those cases with some -­ even if they’re not suspect — with some rigor to say, do we really think that Congress was doing this for uniformity reasons, or do we think that Congress’s judgment was infected by dislike, by fear, by animus, and so forth? … What happened in 1996 — and I’m going to quote from the House Report here — is that “Congress decided to reflect an honor of collective moral judgment and to express moral disapproval of homosexuality.” Is that what happened in 1996?
MR. CLEMENT: Does the House Report say that? Of course, the House Report says that. And if that’s enough to invalidate the statute, then you should invalidate the statute. But that has never been your approach, especially under rational basis or even rational basis-plus, if that is what you are suggesting.

via A Remarkable Exchange in the DOMA Case » Dispatches from the Culture Wars.